Andrew Garcia supplied the most memorable performance from tonight’s American Idol Hollywood week show.

We loved Andrew’s original audition, when he impressed the judges with a rendition of Sunday Morning and were expecting great things from him during Hollywood week.

He didn’t disappoint with his emotional and introspective version of Paula Abdul’s ‘Straight Up’, it’s just a shame that Paula wasn’t around to see it. We think Andrew’s version was 100 times better than the original!