Crystal Bowersox suffered from favourites syndrome tonight, when a good performance suddenly wasn’t good enough because the judges were expecting it to be great.

We loved Crystal’s rendition of ‘You Can’t Always Get What You Want’ and think that the Rolling Stones track really suited her voice but it was the obvious choice for her and it might have been nice to see her try something a little different. Wild Horse might have been an interesting song for her.

Randy Jackson said that he loves her but it wasn’t her best performance, Ellen DeGeneres said she was born to be on stage and wa glad to see her personality shine through, Kara DioGuardi liked how comfortable she was on stage and Simon Cowell thinks she was beaten by Siobhan.