It never hurts to look good on American Idol, especially if you’re hot enough to impress cougars on the panel.

Casey James revealed before his audition that he had been in a serious motorcycle accident and lives in pain every day. However Victoria Beckham and Kara DioGuardi weren’t interested in his pain, or his singing for that matter during his American Idol audition.

Casey had an ok voice, a forgettable personality and after his performance, Simon said “This is a bad audition…No charisma, no effort.”

Kara and Victoria couldn’t have disagreed more, exclaiming that he looked like a model and making him take his hair down and his shirt off.

Simon Cowell called the whole thing “really embarrassing,” but after Kara and Vic coerced Randy to give him a yes, Casey sailed through to the Hollywoodstage . We wonder what Kara and Victoria’s husbands think of that?