Paige Miles may not always hit the notes she needs to, but no one could accuse her of being boring.

The 22 year old sang Honky Tonk Woman for the judges on last night’s live show and we loved the personality she brought to the stage.

Randy Jackson liked it, and Ellen DeGeneres loved that she used the stage and has lots of star quality. Kara thought she did a great job, despite having laryngitis this week. Simon Cowell praised her for battling through laryngitis, but thinks the song was a little generic. He added that she still hasn’t “quite connected” but was impressed by her vocals.