Tim Urban sang David Cook’s “Come Back to Me” on tonight’s American Idol show and we weren’t totally blown away by his performance.

We can’t remember him at all from the audition shows, which is often a bad sign and tonight we found him really very bland. “He’s got a nice voice,” Simon commented, whilst Kara picked up on the “shaky chorus.”

Tim moved through to the next round though, so maybe we don’t know it all!