Scott Macintyre sang Bruce Hornsby’s “Mandolin Rain” on last night’s American idol show and it seemed to be a return to form for the singer.

He still didn’t seem as comfortable as he does behind a piano, but I really do think that Scott is one of this years stand out acts!

Simon Cowell, though not enamoured with his song choice, told him “he is the only one from the night that he will really remember, and he will be amazed if he doesn’t sail through to the next round.” In a repeat of their infamous exchange at the auditions, Scott and host Ryan Seacrest once again shared a hi-five.

Judges Comments:

Randy – “This wasn’t the most perfect vocal, but you had to hit the big notes you really hit them.”
Kara – “You move mountains. You’re passionate about it and you don’t make excuses.”
Paula – “You blessed us all with your gift.”
Simon – “You’re growing on me. I think there are better singers in the competition. You’re the only one I think I’ll remember.”