I thought she was never going to go! But tonight Scottish Ashley was booted off I’d Do Anything on BBC One.

Ashley has faced harsh criticism from Andrew Lloyd Webber for weeks now, and I was surprised she lasted this far.

I like Ashley’s voice, and don’t think she is as awful as the Lord implied. However, listening to her ‘Don’t Cry For Me Argentina’ with Niamh tonight I realised that Niamh’s voice stood out and had a very unique quality. Ashley could have been anybody, I have heard many voices just like hers in various competitions. The girl is talented, but she just wasn’t special enough.

The question now is, can Niamh last another week? She has been saved by Lloyd Webbet twice now, surely if she ends up in the bottom two once more she’s going home.