It appears that auditonee Joanna Hindley was not telling the whole truth when she appeared on last weeks X Factor show.

The mother who sang Fields Of Gold said that she had not got very much confidence and had never taken part in anything like the X Factor before.

However in this weeks Now Magazine it has been revealed that Joanna was actually the winner of last years She’s The One talent show, which was also presented by Kate Thornton and judged by Louis Walsh. In fact as her prize Joanna appears on a duet with Westlife on their album ‘Allow Us To Be Frank’.

Many X Factor fans now suspect than Joanna is actually a plant, and not a genuine X factor contestant. So will she win? That remains to be seen…..

Discuss this and loads of other X factor news on our forum NOW!