Who’s your favourite X Factor judge this year?
Loading ...Seems like Cheryl’s popularity is taking a bash this year, while people have been much kinder to Dannii Minogue. At the same time, Simon’s been harshly criticised for dumping Lucie last week while Louis got a little bit of sympathy for his behaviour during Stephen Gately’s funeral.
So, we thought we’d poll you guys to see which judge you’re loving the most this year. After you’ve made your vote, leave us a comment to tell us which judge you chose and why!
Louis is GOD.
Simon: Masterfully crafted an entertaining series. Has done well managing and defending his acts.
Louis: Very entertaining interaction with the judges. Inspired song choices for the twins by playing to their performance strengths.
Dannii: Mismanaged two of her acts and is only now recognising the blindingly obvious that the show is much more than a singing competition.
Cheryl: Screwed up by sending Rikki and Lloyd to the live shows, Duane and Ethan were much stronger singers and more charismatic than her choices. Hasn’t done much to make Joe interesting.
Doozer – great run-down of all the judges. Cheryl definitely failed in her choice of finalists, and I like what you wrote about Louis – for all his faults, he has managed to steer Jedward in the right direction.
Thanks Gerard. I think in this series we have definitely seen who has industry experience in mentoring and managing acts. Cheryl has spent too much time on other commitments rather than helping her (poorly chosen) contestants.
dannii minogue
! x
best judge.
Dannii…She seems to truly care about her acts. She really has done nothing wrong with them and somehow has managed to lose two of her acts in a row. Such a shame
Dannii is the best judge really cares about her acts and is much better looking than the chav
Dannii all the way. As for Cheryl, she’s become the Saturday
night TV Chav.
I think Cheryl seems to be a very nice and down to earth person. I can totaly relate to her and I think calling her a chav i so rude and only exposes your background and manners.
I have got nothing against Danii. I just think Cheryl is more natural and nice kind of person, and I like her more.
Dannii is by far my favourite. She’s been my favourite since she started on the show, but I think this year people are finally realising that she’s actually a very genuine person.
Cheryl’s great, but there’s an awful lot of hype that I don’t buy into, and I think she did herself no popularity favours with the Daniel Fox debacle!!!
Louis…I can’t say I think he’s great, but the shows when he wasn’t there after Stephen Gately died really felt wrong and like they were lacking something, so I’d miss him if he wasn’t there.
Simon…He’s brilliant and I’m not convinced the show would work if it wasn’t for him!
But no one, and I mean NO ONE is better than Dannii!!!!!
Danni: Professional, fair and so underrated!
Simon: Hilarious!
Louis: Would be missed if he wasn’t there so I suppose he’s ok!
Cheryl: Losing her sparkle to Danni because she can’t judge the show properly. She slated Danyl and he should win as he is the most talented!
DANNI ALL THE WAY!!!
Danni :Is the best judge she is totally committed and
gives 100% to her acts. Has been the victim of
Simons manipulation this year. Every year she
has acted professional even through the most
unprofessional behaviour of Sharon & Louis.
Cheryl : Has spent to much time focusing on her own
solo career at the expense of her acts. Not
committed enough thinks her looks are enough.
Louis : Complete waste of space, he is only interested
in making cheap, sarcastic comments.
Simon : Has completely lost his integrity, he was
always known for his honesty and giving fair
comments. This year he has completely favoured
Danyl over Olly & Jamie and is only interested
in ££££££££’s.