Comments on: Xtra Factor The AfterMath: This Weeks Song Choices

By: ROD BELL

ROD BELL — Sun, 12 Nov 2006 09:59:40 +0000

YOU are right on all counts LuLu Mc, I am a fan of ETON ROAD obviously but I also genuinely liked ANTHONY’S soft part in the middle, many songs have this and it ADDS a classical feel to it, these lads try it all and had that been maybe at the start or longer then it could have been awesome, the week was love theme ,the song was a bouncy simple early 60s pop type, the lads captured the era, the fun element and added the sensitive touch with ANTHONY’S solo when recording and the ideas and styling this group can inject then the result will be awesome.I loved the quirky routine, didnt want the performance to stop and THATS what music is all about .They are great and I also agree with the CELINE DION comment also an amazing voice and singer. THE LADS DELIVERD AGAIN AS THEY HAVE WEEK AFTER WEEK and at least their routine wasnt like some of the acts waving an arm or arms about as if they are cleaning windows week after week.ROD Newcastle

By: LuLu Mc

LuLu Mc — Sat, 11 Nov 2006 18:10:18 +0000

with u Rod. Eton Rd have the whole package. X Factor is surley not just about the voice – if it was we would all luv Celine Dion – it’s about sparkle, pazaz, that little extra that you just cant put ur finger on. Eton Rd have bucket’s full of it. Leona and Ben both have amazing voices but I just know that it is the Eton Rd boys that I look foreward to seeing every week! Love em’.

By: ROD BELL

ROD BELL — Sat, 11 Nov 2006 14:28:28 +0000

WELL Erin maybe I was a bit harsh to say screaming, its more forceful singing and labouring on a particular word or note that I dont like the way she does that, She has a great voice, the softer parts of a song cause her problems and the songs Simon is giving her dont help, SHE WAS AND IS THE BEST FEMALE SINGER IN THIS YEARS CONTEST but she needs certain songs to show fully her wide vocal range.ETON ROAD, have the whole package in MY view only,many will disagree but they would be my winners.ROD,Newcastle

By: Erin

Erin — Fri, 10 Nov 2006 16:56:18 +0000

Aw no i disagree ttly when uv sed leona screams parts n cnat do soft…she so can :O…shes amazin:O….i thot i saw ont he xtra factor tht mcdonlad brothers were singing ur beautiful-james blunt? maybe not…Eaton road will do well:) xoxo

By: ROD BELL

ROD BELL — Fri, 10 Nov 2006 15:45:32 +0000

MacDONALDS HAVE A GOOD SONG, could work again for them, ETON ROAD will do great with that bouncy BEATLES song, LEONA will struggle again singing the soft parts of the song then do a screaming bit to add effect where no effect is necessary IF YOU can sing the song right in the first place.BETTER and more varied week of songs though,better than an ARTISTE themed week.JUST HOPE SIMON LEAVES EARLY AGAIN so we can avoid his bullying tactics and shocking manners.ROD,Newcastle.